Trattoria Dell’Arte

Reviews

• Jennifer R.

  star star star star star_border 11 June 2026

  The short: MUCH better experience than my first time. The seafood was super fresh!
  
  The longer: my first time, I went during theatre time and had upstairs seating nightmare. This time, I came during the week during lunch and absolutely loved it.
  
  It was pricey for lunch ($38 for fish), but they did have a price fixe option, too. Our waiter and all the staff were very friendly, our seafood lunch options were delicious- and they used seasonal ingredients, which I appreciated.
  
  This was a great break in the workday, service was speedy, and it is a perfect, perfect spot for a business lunch or midtown reprieve (downstairs seating especially!). I recommend!

• Alexandra H.

  star star star star star 6 June 2026

  This is for sure one of my favorite Italian spots. I've been quite a few times and have always had a great experience.
  
  The food is consistently good and the service is always exceptional. Every waiter we have had has always been super friendly and went out of there way to make god conversation. I will return back to this place every time I am in town.

• Ryan S.

  star star star star star 4 June 2026

  We were attending a concert at Carnegie Hall (across the street) on Thursday, June 27th.  Once the concert was over, we were looking for a dinner in the area around 10pm for a party of four.  
  
  We wanted to leave the Times Square area; however, we didn't feel like doing much searching; therefore, we went with the first place we saw.  What an amazing decision!
  
  It is just north of Times Square; therefore, I was expecting a tiny cramped place with out of control prices.  Well, I was wrong.
  
  This place is massive!  Our server was so incredibly nice. The food was great.  The prices were on par with what you would expect.
  
  I had the Chicken Pepperoni Parmigiana.  I was totally impressed.  I believe the price was between $30 and $35.  You got a very generous serving of the dish.  
  
  I would definitely return to this restaurant again.  Good luck Trattoria Dell'Arte.  We wish you continued success in this not always so easy business.

• Gab G.

  star star star star star_border 13 May 2026

  Visited with three friends and tried a bunch of dishes. Fried artichokes to start were great but not my favorite. We also had a trio of veggies - vegetable tart, roasted seasonal mushrooms, peas & prosciutto - and the mushrooms were amazing. Chicken pepperoni parmigiana was awesome, I liked it more than the one at Quality Italian. Ravioli pesto was the best thing we ate. 101 layer lasagna, Summer spaghetti and Little gem Caesar were all excellent. As for desserts, the Limoncello tart was my fave, though the cannoli was great, too. Service was a bit slow but overall I had a great experience. 4.5 stars.

• Yulan W.

  star star star star star 13 May 2026

  We randomly stopped by this restaurant after a show at Carnegie Hall. Victor took us to the bar and provided one of the best services I've had. The food was amazing and the drink was refreshing. I highly recommended!